Welcome to DiSC 2003
SIGMOD 2002
PODS 2002
 SIGMOD RECORD 2002
 ADBIS 2002
CIKM 2002
CoopIS 2002
 EDBT 2002
 ER 2002
Data Engineering Bul
DEXA_EC-WEB 2002
DMKD 2002
 DPDJ 2002
<<< = DPDJ'02 Papers>>>
HYPERTEXT 2002
ICDE 2002
ICDM 2002
JCDL 2002
KDD 2002
 KDD_EXPLORATIONS 20
KRDB 2002
MDM 2002
MIS 2002
RIDE 2002
SBBD 2002
 SIGIR 2002
 SIGIR FORUM 2002
SSDBM 2002
TODS 2002
TIME 2002
VLDB 2002
VLDBJ 2002

Dictatorial Transaction Processing: Atomic Commitment Without Veto Right


Maha Abdallah, Rachid Guerraoui, and Philippe Pucheral



Return to Volume 11, Number 3, May 2002


Abstract

The current standard in governing distributed transaction termination is the so-called Two-Phase Commit protocol (2PC). The first phase of 2PC is a voting phase, where the participants in the transaction are given an ultimate right to abort that transaction. Giving up that veto right from all participants reduces the overhead of the atomic commitment protocol but also imposes some restrictions on the concurrency control and recovery protocols employed by the participants in the transaction. This paper gives, for the first time, a precise abstract specification of the Dictatorial Atomic Commitment (DAC) problem, resulting from removing veto rights from the traditional Atomic Commitment (AC) problem. We characterize transactional systems that are compatible with that specification in terms of necessary and sufficient conditions on concurrency control and recovery protocols, and discuss the practical impacts of those conditions. From this study, we capitalize on existing protocols that solve the DAC problem, and propose a new protocol that broadens the applicability of dictatorial transaction processing in order to meet the requirements of today's distributed environments. We point out interesting performance tradeoffs, and describe the implementation of our protocol in the context of current transactional standards, initially designed with 2PC in mind.


DiSC'03 © 2003 Association for Computing Machinery